Phil Murphy's Police Chase Restrictions Being Blamed for Death of Two in Toms River

TOMS RIVER, N.J. -- A teenager driving an unlicensed BMW at 118 mph now faces two counts of aggravated manslaughter after crashing into another vehicle and killing two people late Friday night. The incident has ignited a debate about New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy's restrictions on police pursuits in non-violent cases, raising questions about whether the crash could have been prevented if law enforcement had pursued the speeding car.

The Seaside Heights police attempted to track the teen's vehicle, which was recorded speeding on Route 35, but did not chase it due to New Jersey's pursuit policy. This policy dictates that officers may not pursue suspects unless they believe the individual has committed a serious offense or poses an immediate threat to public safety. Criticism of this policy has intensified on social media, with many blaming state officials for the tragic outcome.

Governor Murphy does not directly set the police pursuit policy, as it falls under the jurisdiction of the New Jersey Attorney General's Office. However, his administration has influenced law enforcement strategies, particularly concerning public safety and accountability. Recent updates to the pursuit policy, which reflect his administration's priorities, have prompted discussions about balancing the need for apprehending suspects against the risks associated with high-speed chases.

The policy underwent significant revision in December 2020, focusing on serious offenses and public safety. While the initial updates restricted pursuits for minor offenses, a subsequent policy shift in April 2022 allowed police to pursue suspects involved in auto thefts amid a rise in related crimes. This decision also came alongside federal funding aimed at improving technology to track stolen vehicles, potentially reducing the need for dangerous pursuits.

As authorities continue to investigate the crash and the teen's actions, questions remain about the effectiveness and safety of New Jersey's pursuit policies. The incident reflects a complex challenge for law enforcement officials as they navigate the risks of high-speed chases against the imperative to prevent crime and ensure community safety.