Man accused of killing girlfriend in South Berwick admits to pulling trigger

PORTLAND (WGME) -- Jeremiah Godfrey, accused of murdering his girlfriend Sherri Sweet in South Berwick last weekend, made his first court appearance on Friday. Godfrey allegedly admitted to pulling the trigger, leading to a tragic outcome that left Sweet, the mother of their child, dead from a gunshot wound to the back of her head.

The incident occurred at their home on Brattle Street, where police found Sweet with a severe injury. She succumbed to her injuries and died the following evening in the hospital. During a frantic 911 call, Godfrey reportedly was hysterical, expressing disbelief over the shooting. The police affidavit details how, in the chaos, he shouted, "I can't believe I did that."

In court, Godfrey was mostly silent but acknowledged the murder charge against him. He told authorities that an argument had escalated when Sweet threatened to take him to court for child support, prompting him to retrieve his gun. He claims that as Sweet was descending the stairs, she turned and grabbed for the pistol just as it discharged.

Despite his admission of responsibility, Godfrey's explanation raises questions. He did not clarify how Sweet was shot in the back of the head if she was reaching for the weapon while facing him. His acknowledgment of guilt further complicates the narrative, as he stated, "Obviously I pulled the trigger, yes. Nobody else was there."

This case highlights the complexities surrounding domestic violence and gun access, prompting broader discussions on safety and accountability in such situations. The court proceedings will continue as further details emerge in this tragic case.