In an interview with Wirtualna Polska, Professor Marcin Matczak stated that for 11 years, we have been dealing with an attempt to "deactivate the Constitutional Tribunal." #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #Konstytucja #Prawnicy (translated)
In an interview with Wirtualna Polska, Professor Marcin Matczak stated that for 11 years, we have been dealing with an attempt to "deactivate the Constitutional Tribunal." #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #Konstytucja #Prawnicy (translated)
"In a rule of law, a person who himself violates the law must be removed from office according to the law." #Polsko #ústavníkrize #TuskKaczyński (translated)
"The images we see will be remembered. If we see armed police in a place that should be a temple of law, people really begin to wonder what it’s all about," said Prof. Marcin Matczak to RMF FM. #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #reset #Polska (translated)
"It was not a strategy of repair from the beginning, but a strategy of takeover. And we all saw its end on Friday, and we all, especially democracy, will pay for how it was carried out," concludes Prof. Marcin Matczak. #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #profMarcinMatczak #prawo (translated)
"The images we see will be remembered. If we see armed police in a place that should be a temple of law, people really start to wonder what it’s all about," said Prof. Marcin Matczak to RMF FM. #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #budżetTK #sędziowie (translated)
Therefore, the requirement of 2/3 of the "total number of judges" must be understood as counted from 15, because otherwise these provisions make no sense — Matczak wrote on the X portal. #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #kworum #prawo (translated)
So unfortunately, this is how the spiral of searching for nonexistent legal grounds looks – once you say "A" regarding the suspension, you have to say an even worse "B" regarding the quorum. #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #Prawo #Kworum (translated)
"The images we see will be etched in memory. If we see armed police in a place that should be a temple of law, people really start to wonder what it's all about." #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #Demokracja #PaństwoPrawa (translated)
Marcin Matczak, a famous jurist very critical of PiS, said that the decision was made without legal grounds. #Polonia #CorteCostituzionale #Proteste (translated)
A lawyer very much respected by me, Professor Marcin Matczak, who sharply criticized the actions of the government and its attacks on the rule of law during the rule of PiS, but at the same time did not endorse the methods used in recent days by the judges selected to the Constitutional Tribunal by the current majority, presented a simple solution to the current crisis. #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #DonaldTusk #praworządność (translated)
The author of the post wrote that it was the duty of the President of the Republic of Poland to prevent the escalation of emotions and the threat to the life of the people gathered in and in front of the Constitutional Tribunal building. He described Karol Nawrocki's actions as extremely irresponsible. He added that there are many ways to resolve the situation and referred to physical confrontation. #Polska #prezydent #bezpieczeństwo #PL (translated)
Marcin Matczak wrote that the right wing in the USA wanted to publicly broadcast executions by firing squad, while the president of Poland proposed a discussion about broader access to guns. He assessed that such actions led to the militarization and brutalization of public life and promoted a cult of strength as a source of safety. In his opinion, safety depended on thinking, not strength — both in the past and present. https://t.co/USl51l8al7 #bezpieczeństwo #demokracja #militaryzacja (translated)
Marcin Matczak considered the president's attempt to control whether the judges of the Constitutional Tribunal elected by the Sejm met the requirements as usurpation. He argued that according to the principle of legality, the president would need a clear legal basis for such control, and — as he wrote — there was no such provision. Matczak criticized the hypothetical examples presented by Marcin Przydacz and Zbigniew Bogucki regarding the election of a horse, a monkey, or a person without Polish citizenship to the Tribunal. He described them as science fiction scenarios. He added that if the Sejm chose animals, it could invalidate their appointment with another resolution, just as — according to him — PiS did in 2015 to introduce substitutes into the Tribunal. He noted that in that case, people who had Polish citizenship were elected. In response to the arguments of Przydacz and Bogucki, Matczak presented his own ironic examples of possible presidential control: a test of knowledge about society and the Constitution, a physical fitness test, and a certificate from a parish priest about the candidate's impeccable character. He asked why the president should control one requirement and not the others. Matczak wrote that he considered the whole situation absurd. He assessed that caricatural legal arguments were being constructed so that the president — a potential defendant of the Tribunal — could decide who would judge him. He attributed such a position to Karol Nawrocki and his associates. #prawo #Polska #sędziowie (translated)
Marcin Matczak requested an indication of the provision that would define the competence of the President of the Republic of Poland to examine the actual and legal situation of a judge of the Constitutional Tribunal elected by the Sejm, including the entity, subject, and procedure of such control. He asserted that such a provision does not exist, and therefore the president does not have such competence. He added that the thought experiments of his interlocutor did not, in his opinion, change the fact that the president was claiming rights that the law did not grant him, and his interlocutor was assisting him in this. #Prawo #Prezydent #TK (translated)
The president is a hypocrite here on an extraordinary level. Lawyer Marcin Matczak blamed Karol Nawrocki for the entire turmoil surrounding the Constitutional Tribunal. #TrybunałKonstytucyjny #KarolNawrocki #MarcinMatczak (translated)
Marcin Matczak wrote that Jarosław Kaczyński took political control over the Constitutional Tribunal and placed his deputies and people from his circle in it, to not give up that control now. He added that Kaczyński came and sat on a chair under the Tribunal to watch over it. https://t.co/PYcqV2o3Kg #Polska #TK #politka (translated)
Marcin Matczak accused President Nawrocki of hypocrisy and wrote that he treated Poles like fools. According to Matczak, Nawrocki claimed that the Constitutional Tribunal, completely controlled by PiS people, needed protection from the control of a single party, while at the same time unlawfully blocking judges elected by forces outside of PiS, so that the Tribunal would remain in the hands of one party for as long as possible. #Polska #politka #hipokryzja (translated)
Marcin Matczak wrote that the day before, in "Super Express," he criticized Karol Nawrocki's idea to increase access to firearms in Poland. He claimed that it could lead to school massacres similar to those in the USA and emphasized that, in his opinion, the proposal is particularly bad in the context of the school murder he wrote about. Matczak accused the right of presenting his words as a connection between the president and the knife attack and called its representatives propagandists. He also addressed the president, urging him to focus on Poland's problems instead of concentrating on Donald Trump. He described the USA as a failing country in some social issues, pointing to healthcare and children's safety in schools. In his view, widespread access to firearms contributes to a tragic level of safety there, and a mentally unstable teenager can take a gun from a father. Matczak assessed that the president should not propose changes leading to the militarization of public life. He wrote that Poland has developed through cooperation, not through mutual threats of weapons. #bezpieczeństwo #broń #Polska (translated)
Zbrodnia w Jarosławiu jest straszna - sprawca, w tym przypadku obywatel Ukrainy - powinien być surowo ukarany. Nie powinni być jednak karani atakiem i nienawiścią inni Ukraińcy mieszkający w Polsce. Niestety, już tak u nas jest, że kiedy przestępstwo popełnia Polak, winny jest tylko ten Polak, nie my wszyscy. Ale kiedy przestępstwo popełnia Ukrainiec, to z wielu wypowiedzi wynika, że winni są wszyscy Ukraińcy. #Zbrodnia #Ukraina #Solidarność
Upadek naszego państwa na skutek decyzji polityków PiS w sprawie TK najlepiej ilustruje fakt, że pięcioro sędziów TK, żeby złożyć ślubowanie, musi zrzucić się po 20 000 dolarów, żeby spotkać się osobiście z prezydentem Nawrockim i zrobić to, bo inaczej się nie da. #Polska #TK #Polityka
Claim it. Contact us at [email protected]