Search

Ed Raposo commented that Fachin had said that democracy required the loser to respect the rules of the game. He also mentioned the investigation against Flávio, stated that the STF was waiting for a "turn" and classified a poll as suspicious, concluding that the situation was starting to become strange. #Democracia #Justiça #Política (translated)

Pri questioned whether Gonet had stopped supporting Moraes and wrote that the PGR had expressed to Fachin against Alexandre de Moraes' request to investigate André Mendonça in the Banco Master case. According to Pri, the Prosecutor's Office considered that the reports from the Federal Police did not contain enough evidence to open the investigation. https://t.co/0fa8gVt7jt #Justiça #Política #Brasil (translated)

Reinaldo Azevedo stated that if Roberta Luchsinger was being threatened, her lawyers could request protection from the Federal Police. He also said that the request could be sent to the rapporteur of the case, who, according to him, was Fachin, and classified the rest as baseless talk. #Justiça #DireitosHumanos #Segurança (translated)

Ludmila Lins Grilo said that a media outlet contacted her the night before to talk about her allegations regarding what she called clandestine precautionary measures and pro forma dismissals made by Alexandre de Moraes's office. She contrasted this contact with the lack of communication from the offices of Moraes and Fachin, despite several reiterations that she claimed were well documented. #Justiça #DireitosHumanos #LiberdadeDeImprensa (translated)

Karina Michelin wrote that Edson Fachin received the Federal Police's director-general, Andrei Rodrigues, on Tuesday, October 13, and demanded that all mentions of STF ministers in the investigations be gathered. According to her, Fachin also established that any investigation against members of the Court would depend on authorization from the plenary, after a manifestation from the PGR. Michelin classified the decision as contradictory and stated that, in 2022, the STF itself had decided that a rapporteur could authorize investigations against state judges without approval from the collegiate. She added that, faced with suspicions involving the judiciary's leadership, it would be up to the ministers themselves to decide whether the investigations could proceed. #STF #Justiça #Direitos (translated)

Leandro Ruschel stated that Edson Fachin was advocating for a reform of the Judiciary without altering guarantees, but he questioned which guarantees he was referring to. According to Ruschel, in recent years, the Federal Supreme Court had restricted constitutional rights such as free expression, association, and manifestation, in addition to the right to defense, the natural judge, and due process. He said this had occurred especially with people who did not align with what he called the court's leftism. Ruschel also criticized the defense that the reform should be made "with the Judiciary." According to him, it is up to the Legislative to draft laws, while the Judiciary should apply them and assess their compatibility with the Constitution. He added that courts can propose laws regarding their own organization, but the decision falls to Congress, and they cannot present constitutional amendments. For Ruschel, the expression used by Fachin would be a euphemism for the usurpation of Congress's powers. #Judiciário #Reforma #GarantiasCivis (translated)

The Meio Independente profile stated that Rogério Marinho (PL/RN), coordinator of Flávio's campaign and pre-candidate for the Senate presidency, told Fachin and Gilmar that the Senate would engage in dialogue with the Supreme Court, but would not give up on the impeachment of Alexandre, whose removal, according to him, was non-negotiable. https://t.co/qGhd92L3Bb #Impeachment #Senado #Justiça (translated)

Andre Marsiglia wrote that Fachin had denied Fux access to the Fake News investigation, claiming that he intended to archive it. According to Marsiglia, Fachin stated that 104 investigations still needed to be closed, new ones had not emerged, and the PGR needed to be heard. Marsiglia concluded that Fux would not have access to the investigation and that it would not be archived, and he accused Fachin of treating the public like idiots. #Justiça #FakeNews #Brasil (translated)

Pri stated that Fachin denied Fux access to the fake news investigation, which remained under secrecy. According to her, Fux's request reignited the debate over Alexandre de Moraes's reporting and the possibility of overturning convictions if any flaws in the origin of the processes were recognized. https://t.co/0FWUrdC7Kb #STF #FakeNews #Justiça (translated)

SPACE LIBERDADE stated that Fachin had denied Fux access to the Fake News investigation. According to the publication, the president of the STF said that the information would only be released after the definitive archiving. https://t.co/RBEsAnlPbt #Fachin #FakeNews #STF (translated)

Enio Viterbo stated that Edson Fachin could not deny Luiz Fux access to the Fake News Inquiry, because, according to him, Fux had determined that access should be granted, rather than just requesting it. Viterbo said that, if that were the case, someone would have to present a suspension of the injunction, but he assessed that this did not seem to be the situation. The author also accused members of the STF of having bypassed André Mendonça and Fachin himself to obtain Daniel Vorcaro's cell phone, without Fachin reacting. In contrast, he said that Fachin adopted a confrontational stance after Fux was provoked by a third party to grant an injunction related to Inquiry 4781. Viterbo also stated that Fachin had declared that he intended to make the Fake News Inquiry public and said that this would allow understanding what he called the arbitrariness of Alexandre de Moraes. #Fakenews #STF #Justiça (translated)

Pri stated that Fachin removed Moraes from the investigation into fake news but maintained the actions he had carried out. According to her, the investigation remained in effect, without a concrete decision to close it or make the decisions fully public. Pri also questioned how long the situation would remain that way. #FakeNews #Justiça #Transparência (translated)